Mosaic Co (NYSE: MOS) is hovering just above $32, still trailing its July high of $38.
The earnings release initially looked impressive, with solid EPS growth, healthy statutory profit, and the kind of headline numbers that usually spark momentum.
But a closer look reveals a $652M one-off gain holding up the story.
That’s the sticking point: investors remain cautious about the reliability of Mosaic’s earnings, and until they see clean, repeatable results, the stock’s multiple will likely stay muted.
Analysts, however, are less doubtful, with average price targets suggesting roughly 26% upside. The gap between market skepticism and analyst expectations is hard to ignore.
Action: View MOS as a value play worth accumulating under $34. Taking a position before the reallocation of capital and clearer earnings consistency could pay off as sentiment shifts.
If management keeps executing on asset sales, cost discipline, and margin improvement, the pathway to a rerating into the $38–40 range becomes increasingly credible, and investors positioned early stand to capture the upside.
Hot Sectors (Sponsored)
The stock market is buzzing with opportunities, and I’ve got the insider scoop just for you.
I’ve handpicked the Top Seven Stocks for this quarter, offering you a clear roadmap for growth as the year progresses.
Here’s what makes this guide indispensable:
High-Growth Sectors: Key industries poised to boom this summer.
Expert Picks: Data-driven, not just guesses, for reliable potential.
Profit-Boosting Opportunities: Position your portfolio for a strong finish in 2025.
This isn’t merely a list; it’s your chance to seize the market’s hottest opportunities before they pass you by.
Why the Market Overcorrected and What Comes Next
At first glance, Mosaic’s latest quarter seemed like a clear win. EPS moved higher, profits improved, and management had plenty of positive metrics to showcase.
The problem lies in the details: $652M of those reported profits came from one-off accounting gains, a temporary lift that won’t be there next quarter.
That’s the reason the stock hasn’t rallied hard despite “solid” results. Investors aren’t fooled; they’re reading it as artificial fuel rather than sustainable earnings power.
Still, the market’s caution may be swinging too far.
Stripping out the noise, Mosaic continues to post steady EPS growth supported by resilient demand for fertilizers, which isn’t vanishing anytime soon.
Operational adjustments, tighter cost control, improved allocation of capital, and trimming weaker assets are nudging the fundamentals in the right direction.
This isn’t a broken business; it’s a credibility challenge.
If Mosaic can prove consistency with a few clean quarters, the steep discount investors are applying today starts to look unjustified.
And once confidence returns, the stock has real room to re-rate higher.
In partnership with
Former Zillow exec targets $1.3T
The top companies target big markets. Like Nvidia growing ~200% in 2024 on AI’s $214B tailwind. That’s why the same VCs behind Uber and Venmo also backed Pacaso. Created by a former Zillow exec, Pacaso’s co-ownership tech transforms a $1.3 trillion market. With $110M+ in gross profit to date, Pacaso just reserved the Nasdaq ticker PCSO.
Paid advertisement for Pacaso’s Regulation A offering. Read the offering circular at invest.pacaso.com. Reserving a ticker symbol is not a guarantee that the company will go public. Listing on the NASDAQ is subject to approvals.
Portfolio Streamlining Could Be the Spark
Mosaic has offloaded its Taquari-Vassouras potash mine in Brazil for $27M and, just as importantly, shed $22M in liabilities that would have demanded fresh capital to sustain.
While the deal looks modest at first glance, strategically it acts as a reset. Keeping that mine operational would have required over $25M in new capex with little hope of producing attractive returns.
Letting it go isn’t about shrinking the business, it’s about sharpening the portfolio.
By freeing up cash, management can redirect resources toward higher-return operations that strengthen margins and improve efficiency.
The move signals discipline: Mosaic clearly recognizes where underperforming assets drag on performance and isn’t hesitant to make tough cuts.
From my seat, that shift represents more than simple housekeeping. It’s an intentional strategy that trims dead weight, strengthens the earnings profile, and opens the door for a cleaner, more sustainable growth story.
These are precisely the types of decisions that transform a company from a potential “value trap” into a steady compounder.
AI Proft Wave (Sponsored)
Artificial Intelligence is evolving faster than most expected — and the opportunities are staggering.
A brand-new investor briefing reveals 5 carefully selected stocks at the center of this wave.
Inside, you’ll also discover a hidden “sleeper” stock that’s still flying under Wall Street’s radar.
Experts estimate AI’s impact could reach trillions by the end of the decade, creating life-changing opportunities for early investors.
Don’t wait — claim your free copy of this just-released report now.
[Get your copy instantly]
*This free resource is being sent by Zacks. We identify investment resources you may choose to use in making your own decisions. Use of this resource is subject to the Zacks Terms of Service.
*Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investing involves risk. This material does not constitute investment, legal, accounting, or tax advice. Zacks Investment Research is not a licensed dealer, broker, or investment adviser.
Capital Returns & Analyst Sentiment
Dividends and buybacks aren’t yet Mosaic’s headline act. The real story is whether the Street buys into the turnaround. Right now, analysts are cautious but leaning constructively.
Wells Fargo is parked at a Hold with a $34 target, basically saying “prove it.”
The broader consensus is more optimistic: a Moderate Buy with an average target of $40.38, about 26% upside from where the stock trades today.
That split tells you everything. The Street isn’t pounding the table, but it isn’t abandoning the story either.
If Mosaic’s earnings get cleaner and asset trims translate into margin expansion, those middle-of-the-road ratings are the first to flip. And when sentiment shifts, it tends to move fast.
Don’t Let These Undervalued Stocks Slip Through Your Fingers!
We now send our favorite value picks via text, too, so you’ll get the same actionable news without having to open your inbox.
Sector Tailwinds: Why Mosaic’s Industry Backdrop Still Matters
The fertilizer sector rarely makes headlines for excitement, but what it lacks in flash it delivers in durability, and right now, conditions are skewing bullish.
Global food demand continues to rise without pause, supply chains remain fragile, and producers with reliable scale and capacity still maintain real pricing power.
That stable foundation is what Mosaic is standing on, even if the market hasn’t fully priced it in.
Rivals like CF Industries are already being rewarded with stronger trading multiples for benefiting from the same supportive dynamics.
Mosaic, on the other hand, is trailing behind, which sets up a potential catch-up scenario if the company proves its earnings quality is more than just a one-off story.
Add in the possibility of lower U.S. input costs under a Trump-driven energy policy, and the sector’s tailwinds could provide Mosaic with an even firmer lift.
Key Sector Drivers Supporting Mosaic:
Rising global food demand that underpins long-term fertilizer usage.
Supply chain fragility keeping pricing power in producers’ hands.
Competitors are already trading at higher multiples, leaving MOS room to catch up.
Potential U.S. policy shifts lowering energy costs, strengthening margins further.
Risks and Re-Rating Potential in the Fertilizer Sector
The downside story is fairly direct: Mosaic’s earnings picture is still padded by temporary boosts, and until those fade out, the market isn’t prepared to assign a premium valuation.
Rising wage costs, volatile energy prices, and geopolitical tensions remain very real threats to margins that cannot be ignored.
While selling the Brazil potash asset removes some balance sheet weight, it also reduces geographic diversification, cutting both risks and potential revenue levers if regional demand stumbles.
The upside, however, is equally compelling.
If Mosaic can deliver two or three consecutive quarters of clean EPS growth without relying on accounting tailwinds, the “low-quality earnings” tag begins to lose its grip.
Analysts already highlight a clear route toward the $38–40 zone, and a rerating closer to sector peers would unlock that potential in a meaningful way.
This isn’t about Mosaic chasing breakneck expansion, it’s about proving disciplined execution in a sector built on long-term, structural demand.
Key Risks to Watch:
Reliance on one-off profit boosts undermining earnings quality.
Rising labor costs and energy price swings squeezing margins.
Geopolitical uncertainty disrupting fertilizer trade and supply lines.
Reduced diversification after exiting Brazil, leaving fewer safety valves.
Upside Re-Rating Potential:
Two to three quarters of clean EPS growth could restore credibility.
Analyst price targets already cluster around the $38–40 range.
Peer revaluation shows Mosaic could close its multiple gap quickly.
Structural sector demand provides a durable backdrop for expansion.
Poll: You wake up with insider knowledge of tomorrow’s market. What do you do first?
Betting on the “Steady Improvers”
Mosaic isn’t about to double overnight, and it certainly won’t be plastered across any growth-stock highlight reels.
What it can do is steadily grind higher by trimming unnecessary fat, directing capital toward higher-return opportunities, and leaning into a sector where long-term demand remains non-negotiable.
That may not sound glamorous, but it’s the kind of disciplined execution that builds durable shareholder value.
The Street is still hung up on the $652M accounting bump, yet that lingering skepticism is exactly what creates an attractive entry point.
If management keeps cutting deadweight and stacks up a few clean quarters in a row, the narrative shifts dramatically, from “numbers padded and untrustworthy” to “quiet operator deserving of a stronger multiple.”
Action Recap
✅ Buy Zone: Begin accumulating shares while they trade below $34. This is the window where risk/reward skews in your favor.
✅ Catalysts to Watch: Keep close tabs on the Brazil asset sale closure, the upcoming EPS release, and any analyst target revisions that signal shifting sentiment on Mosaic’s earnings quality.
✅ Medium-Term Target: A reasonable goal sits in the $38–$40 range, but only if the company delivers consistent results without leaning on one-off accounting gains.
✅ Risk Management: Monitor input costs, wage pressures, and geopolitical disruptions carefully. If margins begin to erode despite supportive sector tailwinds, consider trimming positions to preserve capital.
For long-term investors like myself, that’s precisely the kind of profile worth backing: a steady improver, positioned in a sector with structural demand, carrying upside the market has not yet fully priced in.
What I can say from experience is that sometimes the best opportunities don’t scream for attention; they compound quietly.
That’s our coverage for today, thanks for reading! Reply to this email with feedback or any names you want us to dig into next.
Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Undervalued Edge
