The Single-Digit P/E Setup Hiding in Plain Sight

Motorcar Parts of America (NASDAQ: MPAA) just turned in a record $188.4 million first quarter, swinging from an $18.1 million loss to a $3 million profit. 

EPS missed by more than 50%, but it was mostly non-cash noise. The market didn’t care, sending shares up 22% on the day. 

With sales guidance now raised to $800 – $820 million and gross margin trending higher, this is a classic case of a misunderstood value name starting to re-rate.

Why the Market Overcorrected and What Comes Next

For most of the past two years, MPAA carried a reputation problem.

Tariff costs were a constant drag, debt sat uncomfortably high, and quarterly earnings swung enough to keep institutions on the sidelines.

The market lumped it in with the “margin risk” bucket of the aftermarket sector and moved on.

Q1 FY2026 broke that pattern. Revenue didn’t just beat, it came in $8.3 million above estimates and up 10.9% YoY. Operating income flipped from a $6.5 million loss to $20.1 million. 

Net bank debt fell another $7 million. The EPS shortfall – $0.15 vs. $0.31 expected – was almost entirely the result of $3.9 million in non-cash amortization and a $1.4 million one-time tariff impact, not underlying performance.

Guidance tells the real story: sales now expected at $800 million – $820 million  for FY2026, operating income of $86 million – $91 million, and gross margin climbing back toward pre-tariff levels. 

The narrative is shifting from “cost-burdened and exposed” to “operationally lean and market-share hungry.” The stock just hasn’t fully priced that in yet.

From my seat, this is one of those rare value setups where the numbers, the market reaction, and management’s tone all line up.

The operational discipline is in place, the growth levers are clear, and the valuation is still in bargain territory. 

Execution here has a direct path to a re-rating, and the market is only starting to catch on.

Brake & Heavy-Duty Segments Could Be the Spark

MPAA’s brake product line is still early in its growth cycle, but it’s already delivering results. 

Brake calipers produced at the Mexico facility are gaining share in the professional installer market, and there’s capacity in place to ramp volume without major new capital spend.

More production means better fixed-cost absorption, which directly feeds gross margin, currently at 18.0%, with room to climb.

The heavy-duty rotating electrical segment is another underappreciated lever.

Supplying alternators and starters to commercial vehicle channel partners not only adds a steady, high-margin revenue stream, it builds long-term relationships in a market less sensitive to short-term consumer cycles. 

Demand from this segment is rising, and MPAA’s position as a quality-built brand in this space gives it pricing power competitors can’t match.

Both categories share two crucial traits: they’re non-discretionary and they carry higher-than-average margins.

That combination creates a smoother earnings curve and reduces reliance on any one product line or geography.

These aren’t speculative bets, they’re core businesses scaling into bigger roles in the portfolio.

Capital Return & Debt Reduction as Quiet Catalysts

Q1 wasn’t just about sales growth, MPAA also tightened the balance sheet and rewarded shareholders.

The company repurchased 197,796 shares at an average price of $9.94, cut net bank debt by $7 million to $74.4 million, and finished the quarter with $147 million in total liquidity. 

Interest expense dropped $1.6 million YoY thanks to lower borrowings and better rates, and operating cash flow came in at $10 million, compared to a $20.8 million outflow a year earlier.

This combination of debt reduction and buybacks sends a clear message: management sees value in the stock and has the free cash flow to act on it.

Every dollar saved on interest or share count is a direct boost to per-share earnings power, adding to the long-term compounding effect.

In my experience, this is where the setup gets even more compelling.

Strong liquidity, consistent cash generation, and an active buyback program create a floor under the stock while the growth story plays out. 

It’s the kind of quiet catalyst that doesn’t make headlines, but it steadily forces a re-rating as the numbers stack up quarter after quarter.

Don’t Let These Undervalued Stocks Slip Through Your Fingers!

We now send our favorite value picks via text, too, so you’ll get the same actionable news without having to open your inbox.

👉 Click here to get stock picks by text and uncover the best value opportunities!

Sector Tailwinds

The macro backdrop for MPAA is as favorable as it’s been in years.

The average U.S. vehicle age has climbed to 12.8 years, up from 12.6 just a year ago, and total vehicles on the road hit a record 293.5 million.

An older fleet means more replacement cycles for starters, alternators, and brake components, the exact categories where MPAA is growing share.

This is one of those rare industry setups where demand visibility is measured in years, not quarters.

You can’t defer a brake replacement or ignore a dead alternator, which gives MPAA a built-in revenue engine regardless of economic mood swings.

Layer in their USMCA-compliant production footprint and ability to bypass some of the cost and volatility tied to overseas supply chains, and they’re positioned to win business competitors can’t reliably service.

On top of that, sector discipline is improving, pricing is holding, channel inventory is balanced, and retailers are leaning into trusted suppliers.

For a company like MPAA, that translates into more stable margins and more predictable top-line growth.

Risks and Re-Rating Potential

No value setup is without its pressure points.

MPAA still faces potential macro headwinds if consumer spending on repairs slows, and labor cost inflation could pinch margins even as volumes grow. 

Tariffs, while reduced to $1.4 million this quarter from $4.6 million a year ago, remain a variable the company can’t fully control.

Competition in the aftermarket space is also intense, especially as larger players look to protect share in non-discretionary categories.

That said, the valuation leaves plenty of margin for error. MPAA trades at a P/E of 6.7 versus the industry average of 9.3, and its P/B of 0.85 is well below the sector’s 1.53.

If management sustains the $86M–$91 million operating income range and gross margins keep edging higher, a move toward peer multiples alone could add meaningful upside.

From my perspective, the gap between the current multiple and the company’s execution rate is exactly where the opportunity lives. 

The market’s still pricing MPAA like a business battling for survival, while the numbers point to a lean, cash-generating operator in an industry with visible, recurring demand.

That mismatch won’t last forever.

Final Word: Betting on the Rebuilders

MPAA is executing the fundamentals that matter: record sales, margin expansion, debt reduction, and capital returns, all while trading at a valuation that still reflects its past challenges, not its current trajectory. 

The core businesses in brakes and heavy-duty electrical are scaling, the balance sheet is cleaner, and industry demand is locked in for the foreseeable future.

In a market that often overpays for growth with no clear path to cash flow, MPAA stands out as a category leader rebuilding the right way, by delivering results, quarter after quarter.

For value-focused investors, that’s the kind of rebuild worth being early on.

Action Recap

✅ Buy Zone: Accumulate under $14 ahead of brake segment ramp, heavy-duty growth, and Mexico/Latin America expansion.

✅ Catalysts to Watch: Q2 margin improvement, brake caliper volume gains, and heavy-duty electrical contract wins.

✅ Medium-Term Target: $16–$18 on sustained execution and re-rating toward peer multiples.

✅ Risk Management Tip: Monitor tariff policy shifts, labor cost trends, and aftermarket pricing discipline, trim if gross margin momentum stalls.

I see this as exactly the kind of value setup where patience pays. 

The growth levers are already in motion, management has proven it can convert sales into cash, and the market is only starting to re-rate the story.

 Each quarter of consistent execution chips away at the old narrative and builds the case for a multiple that better matches the fundamentals.

That’s our coverage for today, thanks for reading! Reply to this email with feedback or any names you want us to dig into next.

Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Undervalued Edge