This digital auto lender and bank just posted its strongest quarter in years, with EPS up 90% year over year, core return on tangible equity improving 440 basis points to 11.1%, and four consecutive quarters of improving credit metrics.
Stay with this, and you get the full picture of whether the margin expansion roadmap, the $2 billion buyback, and the July 21 Q2 catalyst make this worth adding at current levels.
Growth Watch (Sponsored)
After analyzing thousands of companies, our analysts pinpointed the 5 Stocks Set to Double based on accelerating performance, improving fundamentals, and strong technical signals.
This newly released report explains why these five could be positioned for major moves in the year ahead.
While results aren’t guaranteed, previous reports uncovered gains as high as +175%, +498%, and +673%.
Access the free report before midnight.
See the 5 Stocks Set to Double.
*This free resource is being sent by Zacks. We identify investment resources you may choose to use in making your own decisions. Use of this resource is subject to the Zacks Terms of Service.
*Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investing involves risk. This material does not constitute investment, legal, accounting, or tax advice. Zacks Investment Research is not a licensed dealer, broker, or investment adviser.
Q1 2026: EPS Up 90%, Beat Estimates by 18%, Net Income Swung From a Loss to $319M
Ally Financial Inc. (NYSE: ALLY) reported Q1 2026 results on April 17. EPS came in at $1.11, beating the $0.94 consensus by 18% and up 90% year over year. Net income hit $319 million compared to a net loss in the same period a year ago.
Adjusted revenue of $2.2 billion beat the consensus of $2.14 billion. Core ROTCE, which measures how efficiently the company generates returns on its equity base, improved 440 basis points to 11.1%.
Adjusted tangible book value per share increased 14% year over year to $41.
This is not a one-quarter event. Q1 is the continuation of a multi-quarter recovery that began when management tightened credit standards, shrunk certain portfolio segments, and rebuilt the margin profile.
That hurt earnings in 2024 and early 2025. It is now showing up in the numbers.
EPS $1.11, beat consensus by 18%, up 90% year over year: The trajectory matters more than any single quarter.
Net income $319M vs a net loss a year ago: That swing takes multiple clean execution quarters to produce.
Core return on tangible common equity (ROTCE) 11.1%, up 440bps year over year: Still below the mid-teens target. Room to run.
Adjusted tangible book value $41/share, stock at $45: Paying 1.1x tangible book for a recovering financial.
The stock rose 4.62% on the Q1 print and trades near the 52-week high of $47.27. The recovery is partially priced in. The question is how much is left.
Action: Buy ALLY at $44-$46. Exit if Q2 EPS comes in below $0.90 or NIM guidance drops below 3.5%.
Hidden Supplier (Sponsored)
SPCX opened below prediction-market expectations, a reminder that by the time mega-IPOs hit the public market, much of the easy money may already be gone.
But Dylan Jovine says one smaller public supplier inside Musk’s AI power buildout may still be overlooked.
It builds the power infrastructure Colossus needs to keep running, has a reported $1.5 billion backlog, and may be priced before Wall Street catches on.
Get the ticker with the upside left.
Credit Metrics Have Improved for Four Consecutive Quarters, and That Pattern Matters
The most important number in this thesis is not EPS. It is the retail auto net charge-off rate. In Q1, it came in at 1.97%, down 15 basis points year over year. Retail auto delinquencies fell 17 basis points to 4.60%.
Four consecutive quarters of improvement in both metrics. That is a credit cycle turning, not a fluctuation.
The significance is mechanical. Falling charge-offs mean lower provision expense on a growing portfolio, which feeds directly into net income.
You are not waiting for something to happen. You are watching it happen one quarter at a time.
Retail auto charge-off rate 1.97%, down 15bps year over year: Fourth consecutive quarter of year-over-year improvement.
Delinquencies 4.60%, down 17bps year over year: Also improving for four consecutive quarters.
Falling charge-offs mean lower provision expense and higher net income: The mechanical path is direct.
Full-year NCO guidance of 1.8% to 2% means management expects improvement to continue. That is the commitment you hold them to each quarter.
Action: On July 21, if Q2 charge-offs hold at or below 1.97% and delinquencies continue to decline, hold or add. Above 2.2% means the improvement has reversed.
High-Rated AI (Sponsored)
Louis Navellier’s proprietary Stock Grader system helped flag major winners years before they became household names.
Now, that same $9 million system is flashing its highest rating on one AI stock with 28% year-over-year sales growth and more than 30,000 patents.
He is giving away the name, ticker, and full analysis for free.
Net Interest Margin Is Guided to Expand, and the Math Behind It Is Simple
Ally guided full-year NIM at 3.6%-3.7%, up from 3.47% in 2025. Approximately $38 billion in CDs issued in the high-rate environment of 2023 and 2024 are maturing in 2026 and rolling over at lower current rates.
Meanwhile, the auto loan portfolio continues to turn over toward higher-yielding originations. Both sides of the NIM equation are moving in the same direction.
The digital bank is the structural advantage making this possible.
Ally has 3.5 million primary digital banking customers and more than $151 billion in deposits, all built entirely through digital channels, with no physical branches.
That gives Ally lower-cost, more stable funding than wholesale borrowing – a genuine moat on the funding side.
NIM guided 3.6%-3.7% for 2026, up from 3.47% in 2025: Funding costs and loan yields both improved.
$38 billion in CDs maturing in 2026: Rolling over at lower current rates cuts funding costs directly.
3.5 million primary digital banking customers, $151 billion in deposits: Low-cost, stable funding base.
NIM guided upward on two independent drivers simultaneously. That kind of expansion is more durable than a single driver.
Action: On the Q2 call, if quarterly NIM lands above 3.55%, the full-year guidance is on track. Below 3.4% means funding cost repricing is slower than guided.
The $2 Billion Buyback Is Active, and Tangible Book Value Is the Right Multiple to Watch
Ally’s board authorized a $2 billion share repurchase program, roughly 14% of the market cap at current prices. Combined with the $0.30 quarterly dividend, that is an aggressive capital return commitment for a recovering financial.
A company buying back 14% of its stock while improving credit and margins is making a statement about where management thinks the stock goes.
CET1 at 10.2% gives Ally room to sustain both the buyback and the dividend without stretching leverage.
$2 billion buyback, approximately 14% of market cap: Aggressive for a recovering financial.
$0.30 quarterly dividend, approximately 2.6% yield: Income component while the recovery plays out.
Tangible book value $41/share, stock at $45: 1.1x tangible book is cheap for a bank with improving returns.
At 1.1x tangible book with ROTCE improving from near-zero to 11.1% and targeting mid-teens, the stock is not pricing in full recovery.
Banks with mid-teens ROTCE typically trade at 1.5x to 2x tangible book. That gap is the re-rating story.
Action: If ROTCE reaches 13% by Q4 2026, the mid-teens target is in reach, and the stock rerates toward 1.5x tangible book, implying approximately $61. That is when you add, not wait.
How ALLY Compares Against Capital One and the Consumer Auto Finance Peer Group
Ally competes directly with Capital One, which has a broader franchise but similar auto lending exposure.
Ally’s advantage is focus – more than 70% of the loan book is consumer and commercial auto, with one of the deepest dealer relationship networks in the country.
Among pure-play consumer lenders, Ally’s combination of a digital deposit franchise, a captive-level dealer network without being captive, and an improving credit profile makes it a unique asset.
The 14 analyst Buy ratings with zero Sells and an average price target of $54.11 against a current price of $45.57 reflect a community of analysts who see the gap between the current multiple and where the stock trades once ROTCE reaches mid-teens.
Capital One trades at a meaningful premium on price-to-tangible-book: Ally is cheaper on the metric that matters for banks.
14 analyst Buy ratings, zero sells: Unusual analyst unanimity for a recovering financial.
Average analyst target $54.11, current price $45.57: An 18% gap that closes as ROTCE improves.
Higher new car prices from tariffs redirect consumers toward used cars. That is exactly where Ally’s dealer network originates most of its loans.
Tariffs are a headwind for new car dealers. For used-car lenders, they are a volume catalyst.
Action: Compare ALLY and Capital One on price-to-tangible-book at each earnings cycle. If the gap widens further over two quarters, rotate.
Poll: Seth Klarman of Baupost Group is one of value investing's greatest practitioners — often more secretive than even Buffett. Which of the following best describes his core investing philosophy?
The Risks Are Specific, and Both Come Down to the Consumer
Auto lending is consumer lending. Ally’s credit improvement has been happening in a stable labor market.
If unemployment moves materially higher, delinquencies rise faster than the portfolio turns over to newer vintages, and the charge-off trend reverses.
Interest rate sensitivity is the second risk. Ally is asset-sensitive near-term but liability-sensitive medium-term.
Near-term rate cuts are a tailwind. A sustained rate spike reverses the NIM expansion story.
Unemployment sensitivity is the primary credit risk: Charge-off improvements track directly with labor market conditions.
Rate spike reverses the NIM expansion story: Liability sensitivity kicks in if rates move materially higher.
Auto lending concentration at 70%-plus of the loan book: Less diversified than Capital One or large banks.
Neither risk is a surprise. Both are disclosed consistently. You are buying a recovery where macro conditions are currently favorable, and the data is confirming the thesis four quarters in a row.
Action: Hard stop at $38. Charge-offs above 2.5% plus NIM guidance cut in the same quarter means both theses broke. Exit at $38.
Final Word: Four Quarters of Improving Credit, Q2 Earnings on July 21, and 11x Earnings
From a net loss to $319M in quarterly profit, with credit improving for four quarters in a row. NIM guided higher. $2 billion buyback is active. Eleven times trailing earnings against $41 tangible book. Fourteen Buy ratings, zero Sells.
Buy ALLY at $44-$46. Hard stop $38. Target $54 near-term. Upside to $61 as ROTCE reaches mid-teens.
Setup Scorecard
Entry Window: $44-$46. Near 52-week high but not stretched at 11x trailing earnings and 1.1x tangible book.
Catalyst Watch: Q2 2026 earnings July 21, retail auto charge-off rate vs 1.97% Q1 baseline, Q2 NIM vs 3.55% checkpoint, ROTCE trajectory toward mid-teens.
Upside Setup: Charge-offs hit 1.8% per guidance, NIM reaches 3.7% by year-end, and ROTCE approaches 13%. Stock rerates from 1.1x to 1.5x tangible book, implying approximately $61. The average analyst target of $54.11 is the first step.
Downside Cushion: $41 tangible book value, $2 billion buyback active at current prices, 14 analyst Buy ratings, four consecutive quarters of improving credit, 2.6% dividend yield.
What Moves It Next: July 21 Q2 charge-off rate, NIM for the quarter, ROTCE progression, and any update on the $2 billion buyback pace through mid-year.
That's our coverage for today; thanks for reading! Reply to this email with feedback or any [blank] stocks you want me to check out.
Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Undervalued Edge
